This pair of size "12 1/2" Nike cleats was worn by Pujols in 2006. Photos on Getty Images match this pair of cleats which Albert wore during that season. According to the Nike manufacturer's tag on the inside, the shoes were made in 2005. Embroidery galore make these stand out: "WWJD", "PUJOLS", the Dominican flag, a Christian cross, "WWJD" (heel), and "5."
The cleats show consistent use with dirt remnants on the bottoms and soil on all angles. Pujols signed ("9-10") both in black felt tip.
PSA/DNA Auction House Letter
A similar pair sold for $3,000 with a Pujols Foundation COA on 7/27/2011.